Subscribe RSSRSS | ABOUT | | ADVERTISE | JOBS
SonicFlare Hi-Fi Get Hip
SonicFlare Get Hip hi-fi guide
SonicFlare Get Hip Super Systems
SonicFlare Get Hip hi-fi is your wingman
SonicFlare Get Hip Sonic Circle

Vegas07 Bel Canto Answers Your Questions: USB or SPDIF?

by Josh Ray, Jan 22 '07

 Mg 4047-1

For all you computer audio junkies, you're probably contemplating connection methods: computer-centric USB or tried and true SPDIF? The answer? Depends on the DAC. Bel Canto showed the same setup last seen at HE2006 -- $9000 Pioneer EX speakers, $1995 Bel Canto DAC3 (with preamp) and $4995 REF1000 monoblocks. Check out our HE2006 coverage for more about the baby TADs and the rocking sound.

When I rolled into the room, the Bel Canto crew jumped up and said, "SonicFlare Josh, you've gotta check this out!" See, Bel Canto was running two computers into their DAC3. A Mac Mini fed the USB port while an HP media center PC fed SPDIF. So we sat down to listen to some tracks and talk smack about the death of the CD. As for USB vs SPDIF, well, USB gets the shiny gold star. We're not talking a slaying or anything, but USB was the champ.

Of course, this wasn't a completely fair test. How much did the computers contribute? Macs are typically more audio oriented (and spend more on quality internal parts). The word on the street is USB has better jitter reduction and a purer signal path. Then again, it's all how you implement it. People have found the Grace m902's USB interface to suck wind compared to its other digital inputs. Also, Bel Canto really went buck wild with their USB input and integrated three buffer stages.

Additionally, "sounds better" is, at some point, subjective. A little brightness or muck may work for your system. But for those who doubt the emergence of USB as a legit connection method, well, doubt no longer. USB is officially Audiophile Approved™.

Comments

Good stuff, I'm looking forward to continued developments in the world of computer audio as audio designers continue to pare down the many devices and stages that now make up the signal path from source to sound. Also, unless I'm mistaken, Bel Canto jacked up the price of the DAC3 on launch to $2500 (or so it says on their website).

What I'd really love to see one of these days is a shootout between a Bel Canto DAC3, a PS Audio Digital Link III, and an Empirical Audio modded Benchmark DAC1 I2S all being driven by the same computer. Comparisons in the audio world are really too hard to make unless they are head to head (and even then sometimes difficult). Anyhow, keep up the great coverage.

Posted by: Audio_newb at January 22, 2007 6:07 PM

Completely ridiculous test. 'Must use the same source equipment, and match levels to be meaningful. Supporting such a test, as mentioned above, only starts another waste-of- time cabling issue kind of thing. Bel Canto would be better off relying on their quality equipment to speak for itself.

Posted by: No Strings at January 22, 2007 7:30 PM

Nice post and very interesting to see PC Audio is coming so strong. I wonder why nobody mentioned it yet.

What kind of media players are they using?

Posted by: Simon at January 23, 2007 11:38 AM