studio
contact
rss

Nova Physics Memory Player -- Digital Revolution?

Bookmark and Share

by Josh Ray on December 19 '06

 Sitebuilder Images Mistystack-433X619

There's a bit of buzz going around the audio forums about a new digital product called the Nova Physics Memory Player. This $10k CD player claims to squeeze every last bit out of a CD, store it on the internal drive, correct the information and then play it back so it sounds BETTER than the original master. So far the word on the street is this:

"The Nova Physics Memory Player is the best sounding source component that I have ever heard." Arnis Balgalvis, Positive Feedback

"...the Nova Physics Memory Player stands as the standard upon which high-end digital playback will be judged." Clement Perry, StereoTimes

"The MP is fundamentally different, no make that better, no make that much better in that there is not one area of performance that I can compare to anything put forth by a CD player that I have personally heard or owned." Greg Petan, StereoTimes

Everyone who has heard the Nova Memory Player does claim it is one of the very best digital transports they have ever heard. Nova Physic's claimed revolutionary technology is "Read Until Right." RUR performs multiple reads of the CD to make sure every last 1 and 0 is extracted. Then it corrects nasty errors and outputs the signal through buffered memory and a tube output stage.

But the question on everyone's minds is if the Nova is simply a glorified computer with Exact Audio Copy. EAC is a free ripper like iTunes, except that it does multiple reads and corrects any errors and then outputs the signal through your computer's buffered memory. So what is the difference between the Nova Memory Player and a computer with a USB DAC? From the Audio Asylum thread:
 Sitebuilder Images Rur Man Dark Edge Red-244X494
"Both reviewers seem so ready to accept that the reason MP sounds so good to them is due to the claims made by MP about ECC and Parity Bits, etc.
What is so PAINFULLY missing from both reviews is the comparison of MP with high-quality PC Audio devices, not run-of-the-mill PC equipped with a generic sound card but ones with better PS, serious parts, BUT without this ECC/Parity Bit business. I would nominate some recent offerings from companies like Empirical Audio, VRS, and various modding outfits."
Jon_L

Computer audio is potentially vastly better than any CD transport. No jitter = no digital nastiness. If you're not hip to the whole computer audio revolution, check out the SonicFlare computer audio archives. You'll find coverage of USB DACs between $499 and $1995 from the likes of PS Audio, Bel Canto, Scott Nixon as well as articles about why jitter is the bane of CDs.

So while a number of reviews around the industry are claiming the Nova is the best thing to happen to digital, there's a major following of those that believe a $1000 computer and $2000 DAC will sound just as good, if not better. Harry Pearson is rumored to be in love with the Memory Player, so expect this controversy to go nuclear shortly.

There's more information about digital jitter, RUR and so-forth at the Nova Physics website. But be prepared. As Jake_LA put it:

"Who's the 8 year old who put this site together? I'm going to spend 10 grand from these guys?"

Yeah, it's a stunner. A pic of a robot jumps around a site propagated with pictures of suns, stars and clay figurines. Then there's the product photography that appears to have been taken in the 80s. Is that photoshop trickery or was the Memory Player actually developed in the 80s? And, of course, some will find it hard to take this product seriously when its main technology is named after a robot stage drama called RUR that premiered in 1922.

Comments

I say rip it to your PC using EAC (free). Buy the Sonos bundle with ZP80 zone players (~1000 bucks). Put all your music files on an external hard drive (Network Attached Storage lets you use the drive with the PC turned off too!) Put a good-as-you-want DAC on the digital output of the ZP80 in your "serious" system and enjoy. Im thinking that the Sonos wireless controller is a heck of a lot more convenient than the "Notebook PC by Dell" that you use with the Memory Player. Heck, I'm even playing with the "recording" version of the Burwen Bobcat plug-in for Windows Media Player, with interesting (very good) results. Just don't tell your audiophile friends you're using "EQ" on your "recordings"...
The robot jumping around on the website is hilarious!!!
RUR = Rossum's Universal Robots = historically the first time in which the word ROBOT was used Interesting play. This machine, however, doesn't seem to differ from well-executed PC audio (but that's already been covered). See you in the funny papers
personally I believe that the Nova player will be quickly debunked as nothing more then a clever attempt to hi-jack unsuspecting "audiophiles" who have little to no experience with computers and how they actually work. Let's face it - if what the Nova guys are saying is all true, I'd love to know how any computer would be able to boot from a cd-rom; how any piece of software would ever hope to work, etc... 10k? ridiculous!!!
I have been trying to keep out of these threads on Audio Asylum, since I am a competitive manufacturer. But I find it amazing that the Memory Player is never called a computer in the reviews, even though that's what it is. The company knows that if they call it a PC, it will turn off a lot of audiophiles who are afraid of using a computer and putting one in a high-end system. And somehow they have convinced the reviewers not to mention it is a computer too. The reviews use very vague language to skirt that issue, which really makes me question the intergrity. The other thing that gets my dander up is that they are essentially taking credit for other computer developers work by claiming that they are doing things uniquely. Typcial marketing BS - describe a common techmnology differently and call it unique, or even trademark your silly phrase. Public perception is that you are a great inventor. That website is an affront to high-end audio dignity! And the bar is really low around here too (present company excluded).
Why DACs are actually more computer-like than the memory player: DACs are multitasking machines having to read from transport, write into buffer and write from buffer into the D/A. Clocking straight from transport to D/A simply risks jitter and errors but still maintain multitasking. The memory player is a single-task machine which is simpler and more effective way of handling jitter. I'm certainly not part of the developing team or an owner - The price is high but it does give you 3 in one combo (CD transport, D/A, Pre-Amp) with sound quality that is at least among the best. I agree that 10k is a lot from first sight but if you include the controlling software development, huge RAM (at least 1 GB) - and being a first product of its kind on the market, the price is about right. A good D/A alone costs about 5k. A good pre-amp cost at least 5k. Add a good transport, digital cable and interconnect and you'll get to around 15k with sound that will at best give you 80% of the memory player, simply because of better use of technology, shorter signal path and much less devices. I'm sure that once competition will apear, the price will fall but right now, this is the only solution to totally overcome the problems with CD standard.
I agree with Josh, this device offers nothing over a computer with EAC installed. But I differ from Josh in that I don't think buying a $2000 DAC is necessary, jut buy a $300 Squeezebox!
Isn't that what most of the people who care about good sound want ? A player, recording machine and pre-amp that can be fully integrated into your listening room. Who want to fiddle with meters of cable running from your gear to your computer, handling portable hard drives, delve into the miracles of the recording software ? No, thanks. I don't want to look at a PC and monitor in my living room. A notebook on the table ? No, thanks again. Hopefully they will offer a small remote control for the player in the near future. Even perfect hassle free recordings of vinyl records seem possible. If this player sounds as good as all the reviews state, it makes all Krell, Meridian, Wadia, Naim and all other ultra expensive players obsolete. Thanks to Nova-Physics for creating this (little bit strange looking) machine. If i could afford it, i would order one right away !!!