Subscribe RSSRSS | ABOUT | | ADVERTISE | JOBS
SonicFlare Hi-Fi Get Hip
SonicFlare Get Hip hi-fi guide
SonicFlare Get Hip Super Systems
SonicFlare Get Hip hi-fi is your wingman
SonicFlare Get Hip Sonic Circle

Burwen Bobcat $10 Billion Sound System!

by Josh Ray, Dec 22 '06

 Issue28 Images Bb-Pics-2-021

"[The Burwen Bobcat] enhances sound when listening, ripping or burning CDs, and high-speed converts files to MP3s that give your iPod or musical cell phone sound comparable with a $100,000 HI-FI SYSTEM!"

Emphasis mine, but all the excessive hyperbole is the property of the Burwen Bobcat, a digital device that is gaining traction in the audiophile underground. Lately, I've been hearing comments about the Bobcat in regards to the computer audio movement, but, uh, musical cell phone? $100,000 hi-fi system? MP3s? Bobcats? Mark Levinson endorsed? Could the BS meter go any higher?

Unlike the $10k Nova Physics Memory Player which is a computer in a box with special software, the Burwen Bobcat is, simply, a Windows Media Player plug-in. While you may see the Burwen Bobcat DAC listed for $1995, the actual magic goes for $199.95 and can be downloaded immediately. The DAC pictured above is called the $1995 Daniel Hertz USB 1 DAC. Presumably, any USB DAC will work fine with the Bobcat software, so check out our USB DAC page for the other players.

So how does the Burwen Bobcat software make your cell phone MP3s sound like a $10000000 hi-fi system? After you rip a CD to your computer, the Bobcat software changes the signal to compensate for information lost during the MP3 conversion process and then compensates for the original digital duplication from the master tape. Basically, it adds information that isn't there:

"It actually improves the signal by adding nearly inaudible high frequency reverberation
and subtle tonal balance correction (equalization)."

But the Bobcat isn't an EQ device exactly. You don't move around sliders, but select from 19 different presets like "vocal" or "classical" or "movies" (just like a $99 Sony boom box down at the 'Shack!). Each time you make a selection, it rewrites the track.

So any "official" reviews yet? John Mazur over at Positive Feedback says the Bobcat crushes a $6000 CD player, while Wes Philips says this of a Bobcat demo:

"In his demonstration of the Burwen Bobcat at HE2005, Levinson played three 128kbps MP3 files through a system that consisted of a laptop running the Burwen software, the USB DAC, and what appeared to be Red Rose's entry-level integrated amplifier and two-way loudspeakers. I wasn't overwhelmed by the sound and suspected that we were being played the "before" tracks that would later be followed by an "aha moment" when the Bobcat wrought its magic. This was apparently not the case, nor were A/B comparisons between 128kbps files and Bobcat reconstructions offered at the Show."

Not exactly stunning. Levinson, the namesake of Mark Levinson and the man behind marketing the Bobcat, said this in a Stephen Mejias Stereohile blog post:

"I would rather listen to a pair of $99 computer speakers with Burwen Bobcat than a 6 figure system without it."

Either he's joking or he's an idiot. My guess is the majority of magic behind the Bobcat is the USB DAC itself, as witnessed by Wes Phillips' audition. Jitter reduction is a pretty serious benefit and, clearly, by having 19 presets to select from, the improvements aren't a universal sort of purification but additive EQ designed to sound pleasing with specific kinds of music.

Check out the Burwen Bobcat site for all the BS you can handle as well as Danny Kaey's post about the Creative Xmod, a cheapie device that seems strangely similar to the Bobcat.

 Sitebuilder Images Heading 102 B Rgb4-552X125-680X161

Comments

Good to see someone calling BS on this. Outrageous and unscientific claims like these are the worst kind of thing for the hi-fi industry.

Posted by: Ward at December 22, 2006 10:26 PM

Somebody buy this please and put it up on a torrent site.

Posted by: Jake at December 23, 2006 8:24 AM

OK, I completely agree about the overblown claims. Yep, absolutely absurd way to market what I think is a product worth considering. I took a chance and bought the Bobcat RE after reading about it being a derivative of an digital audio mastering tool. I believe that a hard disk based file retrieval system is the future, as do many of you. Digital plug-ins offer many exciting possibilities for this concept. Look at the recording industry. Increasingly, this is the ways it's done.
Let's keep our minds and ears open (even when the marketing claims are outrageous). Agree or not with me, digital plug-ins are coming, and this one can sound good and offer real improvements when used judiciously.

Posted by: Dan Grogan at December 24, 2006 12:13 AM

Funny. There's been some discussion on this over in the Stereophile forums as well.

It seems there are some people who think Stereophile should devote magazine space to the Bobcat. We feel it's not worth our readers' time. My experience with it revealed it to be nothing more than a tone control. John Atkinson wrote "This is an inconsequential product from a tiny company that makes impossible claims about what it can do with a terminally sonically compromised medium."

Posted by: Stephen Mejias at December 24, 2006 9:20 PM

Hey Stephen,

Atkinson cracks me up! That's the perfect way to describe the BB.

If SP where to do an article about computer-based devices, I would like to see a roundup of the USB DACs on the market as well as USB to SPDIF/AESEBU converters and the wifi players. This sort of "legitimization" could help audiophiles view jitterless-playback as an accepted medium and promote more companies to create these iPodrific convergence products needed to get the next gen in the game.

Hope Christmas was grand!

Posted by: Josh Ray [SonicFlare] at December 26, 2006 10:26 AM

fake other people's name is bad. could be a felony.

Posted by: fake at December 26, 2006 2:10 PM

Noted and comments removed.

Posted by: Josh Ray [SonicFlare] at December 26, 2006 2:15 PM

umm yeah... post under "Fake" and I'll be sure to take your s.... err.. stuff into consideration.

heh.

whatever.

Felony??? lol!!!

Posted by: Danny Kaey at December 26, 2006 2:56 PM